Visitor Status

Sunday, November 27, 2016

"Proof" For Tithing From Non-Food Items - Abram's Booty Argument

Tithe Teachers Attempt to “Prove” That Tithing Was Non-food items ALSO from the Bible!

Question: Abram’s booty must have consisted of silver and gold and othernon-food items, then how can the tithe opponents say that tithing was only from food?
Answer: First of all, Abram's tithe was a description of an event, a narrative, something that took place in the ancient days. It was not a prescription from God when Abram tithed to Melchizadek.
In Genesis 14:20b the "And he gave him tithes of all" does not specify what that"all" consisted of?
In Genesis 14:24 Abram makes a reference about food though - “Save only that which the young men have eaten, and the portion of the men whichwent with me, Aner, Eshcol, and Mamre; let them take their portion” - KJV.
However Hebrews 7:4 unambiguously declares that Abram gave "the best of the spoils" - the Koine Greek word "akrothinion" literally means"the top of a heap" - implying food. 2 Kings 7 says huge quantities of barleyand flour were recovered from the abandoned Syrian camp.
______________________________________________________________
akrothinion: the top ofa heap, i.e. the best of the spoilsOriginal Word: ἀκροθίνιον, ίου, τόPart of Speech: Noun,NeuterTransliteration:akrothinionPhonetic Spelling:(ak-roth-in'-ee-on)Short Definition: spoil,treasureDefinition: (lit: top ofa heap), first-fruits, spoil, treasure (taken in war).
________________________________________________________________
While it was possible to conclude that Abram's spoils consisted of silver and gold is within the limits of reason, we have to bear in mind that Abram's tithe might have consisted of the following materials as well:
a) Idols representing pagan deities (King David ordered to burn the idols of the Philistines and King Amaziah took the idols of the defeated Edomites and worshiped him)
b) War materials such as spears, shields, swords, javelins, breast plates etc.
c)Prisoners of war
d) Horses and mules
e) Clothes
f) Jewels
g) Crowns worn by the defeated Kings and other items worn to represent the commander/officer ranks
However according to Hebrews 7:4 Abram tithed ONLY the "BEST of the Spoils" -we do not know what the “best of the spoils” consisted of.
Regardless,Abram's tithe incident was a description of a historical event. It was not a prescription either for the Jews or for the Christians.
In ancient Roman, Greek, Carthaginian, Cretan, Silician, Phoenician,
Chinese,Babylonian, Akkadian, Egyptian, Assyrian, Canaanite, Ugaritic, Morrocan,Persian, Lydian, Syrian, Sumerian, and South Arabian societies practiced tithing but their practices varied in terms of where they gave it, when they gave it, the voluntary nature and the amount.
The diversity of the practices between these societies was greater than the consistency.
For example in Arabia tithes were paid on frankincense … but on ground that was watered by rain (i.e. by Baal) twenty percent was due. Does that mean Christians were required to tithe from Frankincense?
Tithing was introduced as a prescription only in Leviticus 27 and that reveals God's blue print for tithing and we should not take other examples before the Law of Moses as an example.

"Proof" For Monetary Tithing - Lack of Direct Definition Argument

Tithe Teachers Offer Various "Proofs" "From Scriptures" For Monetary Tithes!
Some of their “proofs” include:
1. There is no explicit statement in the Bible that tithing was only from food and not from money
2. Abram's booty consisted of non-food items
3. Jacob's promised to tithe from all he would get
4. Money is mentioned in a tithing context in Leviticus 27 and in Deuteronomy 14
5. Jews stored silver, gold and other non-food items in the storehouses
6. The self-righteous Pharisee in Luke 18:12 tithed from his salary
7. The Ma'aser Kesofim argument - Ma'aser Kesofim - Hebrew expression for
Let us examine one by one!
1.  There is no direct statement in the Bible defining the tithes as money.  Tithe opponents take implied meaning by cherry picking the scriptures and derive their own conclusions that tithing is not money to fit their anti-tithing agenda.  Without an explicit statement, we cannot come to a conclusion that tithing was only from food.
Well, there is no direct statement in the Bible about the following either:
  • Nowhere in the Bible, it is explicitly stated that the Canon has been closed
  • Nowhere in the Bible, it is stated that the Divine inspiration of the written scriptures have stopped after the book of Revelation
  • Nowhere in the Bible it is stated that Old Testament should consist of 39 books and the New Testament should consist of 27 books and the Protestant Canon is the only acceptable scripture.
  • Nowhere in the Bible, it is directly stated that slavery is wrong, Christians should not own slaves.
  • Nowhere in the Bible it is directly stated that God is a Triune God!
  • There is no mention about pre-trib rapture in the Bible directly or the rapture will happen in 2 phases.
  • There is no explicit statement in the Scriptures about "assurance of salvation"
  • There is no explicit statement in the Bible which says "Masturbation is a sin"
So what? Without an explicit teaching from the Bible, most of the tithe teachers believe all of the above or most of the above.

Example of Jesus giving implied meaning:
In Matthew 22:31-32 - Even Jesus told the Sadducees that Exodus 3:6 mentions about the resurrection of the dead. Exodus 3:6 does not explicitly state that the dead would be resurrected but mentions about Abraham, Isaac and Jacob in the present tense, therefore it implies about future resurrection. That is Jesus’ point.
Therefore there is nothing wrong in concluding that tithes were only from the produce of the land and from cattle.
Bible were only from food and livestock and that is the empirical definition based upon the prescriptions given in the Law of Moses.

Referring To Extra-Biblical Sources For Research Purposes

Question: Why do you go outside of the 66 inspired books and quote from the Apocryphal book of Tobit, historian Flavius Josephus, Church History, Church Fathers, the Jewish Tamlud and other uninspired sources? It shows that you don't honor the canonicity of the Scriptures and shows that you are so desparate to prove your points even using uninspired sources, the ends cannot justify the means. Learn to stay within the 66 inspired books and respect the canon.
First of all let me clarify one improtant thing:  I believe that the 66 books are the Bible are Divinely inspired, infalliable and authentic word of God. These 66 books are sufficient to lead us to eternal life and guide us to live a life of holiness in this world.
However there is nothing wrong in quoting, alluding to or referring to extra-Biblical sources. The purpose is just to give an FYI to the readers and present it as an additional information for research purposes. It does not mean declaring those extra-Biblical sources as Divinely inspired.
Even the Canonized scriptures refer to/allude to/quote extra-Biblical sources, under Diving Inspiration. That does not mean Biblical writers are wrong in going outside the scripture or attributing divine authority to extra-Biblical sources. The Holy Spirit directed them to make a point using some extra-Biblical sources.
Some examples are given below:
The Book of Jasher mentioned in Joshua 10:12-13 when the Lord stopped the sun in the middle of the day during the battle of Beth Horon. Mentioned in 2 Samuel 1:18-27 as containing the Song or Lament of the Bow, funeral song for King Saul & Jonathan
Book of the Wars of the Lord mentioned in Numbers 21:14 the Book of Samuel the Seer, mentioned in 1 Chronicles 29:29the Book of Nathan the Prophet, mentioned in 1 Chronicles 29:29the Book of Gad the Seer mentioned in 1 Chronicles 29:29, Acts of Rehoboam and the Chronicles of the Kings of Judah - 1 Kings 14:29
Solomon composed more than a thousand songs (1 Kings 4:32), yet only two are preserved in the book of Psalms (72 and 127).
Even in the New Testament Paul quoted from extra-Biblical sources under divine inspiration.
Paul included a quotation from the Cretan poet Epimenides (Titus 1:12) and quoted from the poets Epimenides and Aratus in his speech at Athens (Acts 17:28).
Does that mean Paul dishonored the inspired Scriptures and gave legitimacy to secular philosophers?
Jude 14 quoted in Book of Enoch (Assumption of Moses)
Hebrews 11:37 (sawn in two) - The Ascension of Isaiah 1:9, 5:2, 12
Song of Songs, Ecclesiastes, Esther, Obadiah, Zephaniah, Judges,1 Chronicles, Ezra, Nehemiah, Lamentations & Nahum - never quoted by the New Testament writers.
Matthew 27:42-43 alluding to Wisdom 2:12-20
Romans 1:19-25 alluding to Wisdom 12 & 13
Hebrews 11:35 refers to 2 Maccabees 7
Lord Jesus Himself alluding to Sirach 27:6 when He talked about fruit bearing trees.
Some people say that Jesus celebrated Hannukah referring to John 10:22-23, don't want to open another can of worms by going in that tangent.
"And it was at Jerusalem the Feast of The Dedication, and it was winter. And Jesus walked in the temple in Solomon's porch" John 10:22-23
We can go on and on if we dig deeper into Septuagint vs. Masoretic text, various manuscripts etc.,
Hope this helps!

Intellectual dishonesty of Tithe teachers and their (some of their) tactics!

  • Misleading definitions and terminology.
Existed before the law
Eternal moral principle
Tithing is the 11th commandment
God's insurance policy
God’s plan for your financial security
God's best kept secret
Your tithe testifies that he's alive!
DEBT is an acronym = D-oing E-verything B-ut T-ithing
Local Church is modern day storehouse
Describing first fruits as tithes ...
  • Lack of context
Abram's tithe was from the spoils of a battle and tithe teachers present it as if Abram were tithing on a monthly basis. Jacob made a conditional wow if God brings him back to the promised land. There is no option to make vows on what already belonged to God. Leviticus 27 is about vow making and proves what can be vowed and what cannot be wowed. Only agricultural products and livestock were titheable items in the Old Testament and money was never used in tithing! Misuse and abuse of Malachi 3. The context is God addressing dishonest Priests and not the general public, Matthew 23:23/Luke 11:42 - Jesus was talking to the Pharisees living the law and not to Christians
  • Selective omission
Bluntly saying that Church Fathers taught tithing by quoting Augustine, Jerome and Chrysostom. The truth is Augustine, Jerome and Chrysostom were NOT EARLY church fathers, Augustine sold everything he had and became a monk, Jerome wanted Christians to celebrate the year of Jubilee and Chrysostom mentioned all 3 tithes.
The EARLY church fathers, Ireneous, Justin Martyr, Tertulian and others did not support tithing.
  • Presenting description as prescription:
This is nothing but using true facts to draw false conclusions. Abraham tithing and Jacob tithing were simply description of events and they are prescriptions for neither Jews nor Christians. Abraham had concubines and lied.
Jacob deceived his father and showed partiality among his sons.
Can we follow those examples too?
  • Using anecdotal evidence to establish a doctrine:
"Hey I started tithing and my debts disappear and now I am prosperous" - we hear this often. But the prosperity gospel is not working for MANY who DO TITHE.
What about atheists, people belonging to other religions and ungodly people becoming rich, buying mansions, flying private jets and becoming prosperous after donating to ungodly causes.
  • Logical fallacy:
Tithing existed before the law, therefore Christians should also continue to tithe. Well, the custom of a widow marrying her deceased husband's nearest male relative, (the Levirate law, Yibbum, Halitzah), slavery, animal sacrifice and polygamy - all existed before the law, codified into the law and discussed in the New Testament.
If the tithe teachers follow consistent logic, shouldn't they follow other practices that existed before the law as well?
  • Outbursts of anger and rage:
Calling Christians who question them about tithing as "Heresy hunters, unwilling to submit, rebellious, disrespecting spiritual authority, independent spirit, divisive, subversive, mere head knowledge, lack of revelation, ungrateful etc.," Calling for clandestine meetings, power plays and taking control of the whole situation, yelling and screaming are some of the intimidation methods used by tithe teachers.
  • Ad hominem attacks on Biblical Scholars who oppose tithing:
One example is attacking theologian Russell Earl Kelly's credentials. According to Wikipedia: "Critics say that because his education is from unaccredited schools his Ph.D. is fraudulent. Others will challenge Russell's sincerely and his motives. In response, Russell provides a webpage regarding his education and abilities, including having graduated "cum laude". from the Yale University Institutes of Far Eastern languages while in the U.S. Air Force, earning 22 semester hours and received a B.A. from Southern University Of Seventh Day Adventist, which is fully accredited. He notes that there are hundreds of religious schools that do not want the government telling them how or what to teach.
Having been legally blind since 1989 and not able to drive, his choices of education were severely limited"
Tithe teachers look for opportunities to poke into the personal lives of anti-tithers and try launch a smear campaign.

Benjamin (the last son of Jacob) did not tithe!

Genesis 45:22
To all of them he gave each man changes of clothing; but to Benjamin he gave three hundred pieces of silver, and five changes of clothing.
Genesis 45:13
And you shall tell my father of all my glory in Egypt, and of all that you have seen; and you shall haste and bring down my father here.
"you shall HASTE and bring down my father here" is the key.
Hebrew: ū·mi·har·tem - hurry, haste
Jacob did not tell "Hey Benjamin, tithing is an eternal moral principle and our family tradition and make sure you tithe 30 pieces of silver to Melichzadek and then come back to Egypt" (The Septuagint says 30 pieces of gold but that is besides the point)
Also it is important to notice that Jacob did not insist Benjamin to pay his tithe out of the 300 pieces of silver 1st before starting the journey. Jacob wasted no time in wrapping up the tents and proceeding to Egypt.
Wondering why neither Jacob nor Joseph within whom the Spirit of God was dwelling, did not teach the "concept of the eternal moral principle" to Benjamin.
Hmmm...... it looks like even Jacob broke his own vow!
Genesis 45:23
And to his father he sent after this manner; ten donkeys laden with the good things of Egypt, and ten she-donkeys laden with grain and bread and food for his father by the way.
Genesis 28:22
And this stone, which I have set for a pillar, shall be God's house: and of all that you shall give me I will surely give the tenth unto you.
Jacob did not bother to tithe out of the good things of Egypt, grain, bread and food!!!

Does Luke 18:12 prove that tithes were paid in the form of money?

Luke 18:12
I fast twice in the week, I give tithes of all that I possess. - KJV
Other translations use get, gain, income
Our modern day tithe teachers quote Luke 18:12 and tell us that tithing was paid in the form of money during the time of Jesus.
Let us see what the Greek says:
Strong's Greek: 2932. κτάομαι (ktaomai) — 7 Occurrences
Example: Luke 18:12
I fast twice in the week, I give tithes of all that I possess. - KJV
I fast twice a week; I pay tithes of all that I get - NASB
Matthew 10:9                        Acquire or provide gold/silver/copper
Luke 18:12                            possess or get - ?????
Luke 21:19                            gain or possess lives/souls
Acts 1:18                  get or purchase or acquire land/real estate/property
Acts 8:20                             obtain or purchase the gift of God 
Acts 22:28                          acquired or obtained or bought citizenship by money
1 Thessalonians 4:4                  possess holiness
The rest of the 6 places where ktaomai is used, are not related to earning money as salary or wage.
Therefore it is intellectually dishonest to conclude that in Luke 18:12 ktaomai means earned income or money or salary!
Luke's style is the most literary of all these books. Graham Stanton evaluates the opening of the Gospel of Luke as "the most finely composed sentence in the whole of post-Classical Greek literature."
Knowing Dr. Luke's proficiency and the language skill in Greek, we should wonder why Luke did not use one of the other 2 Greek words for wages: "opsōnia" ὀψώνια and "misthos" μισθὸς
a) Greek word "opsōnia" ὀψώνια - wages
Example: Romans 6:23
For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord. - KJV
For the wages of sin is death, but the gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord. - NIV
Luke 3:14 be content with your wages.
Romans 6:23 for the wages of sin [is] death;
1 Corinthians 9:7 his own charges? who
2 Corinthians 11:8 taking wages [of them]
b) Greek word "misthos" μισθὸς - wages
Example: James 5:4
Look! The wages you failed to pay the workers who mowed your fields are crying out against you. The cries of the harvesters have reached the ears of the Lord Almighty. - NIV
Behold, the hire of the laborers who have reaped down your fields, which is of you kept back by fraud, cries: and the cries of them who have reaped are entered into the ears of the Lord of hosts. - KJV
Variants: Strong # http://biblesuite.com/greek/strongs_3408.htm
(29 times)
μισθὸς (misthos) — 7 Occurrences
Matthew 5:12 your reward in heaven
Luke 6:23 your reward is great
Luke 6:35 your reward will be great,
Romans 4:4 his wage is not credited
1 Corinthians 9:18 then is my reward?
James 5:4 the pay of the laborers, the wage of the workmen, the hire of the labourers
Revelation 22:12 the reward of me with
If Jesus was talking about the self-righteous Pharisee paying tithes out of the income he had earned/salary he received, someone who was excellent in the Greek language like Luke would have used either misthos or opsōnia instead of ktaomai and Luke himself has used the other 2 words for wages elsewhere!
How to interpret Luke 18:12?
a) Scenario 1:
There was such an incident that had really happened and Jesus (reported) mentioned it in Luke 18:12 and made a parable out of it.
If that is the case, the self-righteous Pharisee paid tithes in the form of money to CHARITIES or to the POOR and not to the Levites.
Because in the Jewish tradition (which was condemned by Jesus as the "leaven of Pharisees") they paid one tenth of the income to CHARITES or to the POOR. Only in a gemara in the Jerusalem Talmud it is mentioned as "Ma'aser Kesafim". So if it was a true incident, this Pharisee was referring to tithing to the POOR or CHARITIES and NOT to the Jewish temple or paying the Levitical tithes.
Description does not equal to prescription. It is very unlikely that this Pharisee had lied to God that he had been tithing from all his possessions, "tithing from all my possessions" could be a figure of speech!
b) Scenario 2:
This was a fiction and did not really happen and Jesus made it up to prove another point in the form of a parable.
Parables are pictorial, easily grasped, quickly remembered, and attention holders. Jesus used parables to teach great theological truths. The characters mentioned in the parable were not real but they prove a point.
If this is the case, fasting twice a week and tithing from all possessions did not happen in real life but points out the prideful nature of the Pharisees and how they boasted about their own righteousness even to God!
How to interpret parables (please refer the link below):
Other facts about Luke 18:12
1. Tithing is not the primary subject of this verse. It is a passing/incidental remark to distinguish between pride and humility.
2. It does not command Christians to tithe (and Jews either!)
3. Author's (Luke's) intent was not to teach about tithing but to teach how God disapproves pride and shows mercy to the humble
The Pharisee mentioned in Luke 18:12 lived inside the Promised Land
Tithe teachers forget another important fact about tithing. In order to tithe someone need to LIVE INSIDE the promised land.
Even if we assume that Luke 18:12 is talking about a true incident and the Pharisee here was paying tithes from his wages, Christians (even Jews) living outside the promised land are still unqualified to tithe just because they live OUTIDE the promised land.
Who was justified: the tither or the non-tither?
Ultimately who was justified by God? It was the tax collector who did not claim to have tithed. God was obviously not impressed by the tithing claims of the Pharisee
Fasting twice a week:
Another important point we need to observe in Luke 18:12 is "Fast twice a week" which is overlooked by the cherry picking tithe teachers.
The Exceeding Righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees argument:
Matthew 5:20
For I say unto you, that except your righteousness shall exceed the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees, you shall in no case enter into the kingdom of heaven.
Tithe teachers try to make a connection between Matthew 5:20 and Luke 18:12 and teach us that we need to exceed the righteousness of the Pharisee by paying more than 10% to the local church. In other words non-tithers will go to hell, supported by dreams, visions and visitation of certain tithe teachers. Nothing against dreams, visions or visitations, the real ones (given by the Holy Spirit) do not contradict the Bible, those who have claimed to have gotten revelations that non-tithers would go to hell obviously had fake experiences given by deceiving demonic spirits!
Since Luke 18:12 talks about "fasting twice a week", should we fast 3 times a week in order to exceed the righteousness of the Pharisees. Will a Christian go to hell for not fasting 3 times? None of the tithe teachers that we see today fast for 3 times a day but they cherry pick only the "tithing" part.
Fasting twice a week was never commanded in the Bible neither to the Jews nor for the Christians. Therefore tithing from "all possessions" falls into the same category - not commanded in the Bible.